Health Systems Trust Better Health for all in Southern Africa

Home     News     Publications    Health Statistics    Programmes     Search


Publications
HST provides free electronic access to over 500 health systems research related reports, publications and papers. Close to 300 of these are publications that have been commissioned and funded by the Trust. Topics include among others district systems development, drug supply management, human resource development, informatics, legislation, finance, environmental health, mental health, lessons learnt, nutrition and sexually transmitted diseases / HIV/AIDS. The main publication of the HST is the annual South African Health Review. From 2005 all HST publications will be available in low resolution only. To explore the range of publications HST offers use the Advanced search to search using a variety of criteria.









 

 

 

Failed by the system

HST related

 

Publication Information

1st Author : Roberts, Jaine
Other Authors:
Publisher: Mail & Guardian
Publication Date: 7/2009
ISBN:
ISSN:
Publication Type: Newspaper article
Series:
Issue: 3-9 July 2009

Download Options

To save the pdf "right click" on link and choose "save as"
Type Location Size
jr_mg0330 2418 KB
 

Summary Thandile Qwalela died in the tuberculosis ward of his Eastern Cape district hospital at the age of 48. He was an underground miner from age 20 who served 17 years as a stoper and winch driver on the gold mines.
More Details

Qwalela was diagnosed with TB while in mine service in 1997 and was dispatched to his home in the Eastern Cape. There he started wasting away, while remaining convinced that he would recover. His modest expectation was that his community could be helped with agricultural development. We want to do ploughing as a project, he said. After Ive recovered Ill be able.

He knew nothing of the Occupational Diseases in Mines and Works Act 78 of 1973 or that he was entitled, until the amendment of 2002, to annual benefit medical examinations, free of charge, and thereafter to free examinations every second year.

In the more than 10 years since leaving mine employment he never received medical checks for dustrelated respiratory disease. While employed, he was not told about the legislation or informed of his statutory rights by his local health services. When the legislation was explained to him, he thought it was new. In fact it embodies an occupational disease compensation system that is almost a century old. It guarantees miners not just medical examinations for life, but also compensation for an occupationally related lung disease.

It also requires that when they die, the bodies of all former miners must be autopsied. Did Qwalela have silicosis, a disease that predisposes a person to TB? No one will ever know, because he was buried before the possibility of an autopsy could be raised with his widow. He died and was buried without undergoing an X-ray while he was alive to test for the presence of silicosis and without a postmortem examination.

He left a widow who now survives and feeds three schoolgoing children by collecting and selling bundles of wood. Former miner Machule Mapasa also died in the rural Eastern Cape this year while undergoing TB treatment, at the age of 46. Beginning work on the gold mines in 1981, he was employed for more than 23 years, first as a timber boy and then as a machine operator.

When Mapasa was retrenched in 2004, he was given an exit X-ray, but was told nothing about the results of the examination or his rights under occupational disease legislation.

In 2006 he was admitted to his local district hospital for TB treatment and in 2007 was readmitted to the ward. He died on January 24 this year. He told this researcher: They just say I have TB. Nothing can help me. But I agree with autopsy. I have no objection to that. I want this autopsy.

Mapasas clinical signs relentless coughing, severe pain in his left arm and legs, extreme breathlessness on exertion and pitting oedema all pointed to chronic lung disease. Local health workers did not know of the autopsy requirement for all ex-miners. He received this right as a result of external intervention, discussions with his family and the hiring of a private doctor to remove his heart and lungs. The organs were collected by the National Institute for Occupational Health. Mapasas autopsy report, in May this year, found that there is silicosis as well as dust deposition in regional glands.

The report has now been forwarded to the certification committee of the Medical Bureau for Occupational Disease. His destitute widow and five schoolgoing children await the certification and compensation outcome. Thousands of former miners like Mapasa and Qwalela live in South Africas labour-providing rural areas. Will they continue to die and be buried as TB or pneumonia victims without any possibility of being diagnosed with mining-related respiratory disease? What is happening is a travesty of their rights under occupational disease legislation.

Publication Webpage
   
Keywords This Item is associated with the Following Keywords: .
   
   
You Can Comment on this Item, or View other people's Comments
 

Related content

 Related Publications

 
Mines still fighting to evade costs of silicosis (2009-08-27)
They hide things like that from us. The Hidden Epidemic Amongst Former Miners: Silicosis, Tuberculosis and the Occupational Diseases in Mines and Works Act in the Eastern Cape, South Africa (2009-09-08)
Mining industry fights levy hike (Mines told to pay 30 times more to compensation fund ) (2009-08-27)
A raw deal for miners who contract lung disease (2009-08-27)
Rapid Increase in Tuberculosis Incidence Soon after Infection with HIVA New Twist in the Twin Epidemics (2005-05-19)
 

Related News

 
PRESS RELEASE: The Hidden Epidemic Amongst Former Miners: Silicosis, Tuberculosis and the Occupational Diseases in Mines and Works Act in the Eastern Cape, South Africa (2009-11-11)
AN INVITATION TO YOU TO ATTEND AN HST SYMPOSIUM (2005-01-20)
Govt, mines agree to compensate ex-mineworkers (2008-05-30)
Mining diseases unacceptably high (2002-10-24)
Legislative Updates (2003-03-06)
 

Related Health Statistics

 
Number of admissions for alcohol and other drug abuse (2007-05-21)
Per capita expenditure (non-hospital PHC) (2007-08-17)
Diarrhoea incidence under 5 years (per 1 000) (0000-00-00)
Number of orphans (2007-05-03)
Number of CS occupational therapists (2005-06-22)
 

Related Events

 
The Third Public Health Association of South Africa Conference: Making the Health System Work (2006-05-16)
Masters in Medical Science and Postgraduate Diploma Occupational and Environmental Health (2004-12-06)
OTASA Conference 2004 (2004-05-02)
Burden of Disease and Health Systems Performance (2001-10-07)
24th African Health Sciences Congress (2003-09-28)
 

Related links

 
Centres for Disease Control & Prevention
Environmental Health Project
Health Research Group
Mpilonhle Project
Community Law Centre, University of the Western Cape
The Topsy Foundation
 

Related Content

 
Research: Health Systems Research (2007-08-06)
ISDS Site: Central Karoo District (2004-05-10)
The Research Cluster (2004-02-09)
Treatment Monitor: Abortion (2008-02-14)
Board of Trustees (2004-04-06)
 

   
 

 Contact details       Terms of use       Funder info